For a party that claims to be focused on affordability, they certainly seem to have other things on their mind like tearing down ballrooms, arches, the healthcare system, border security, retirement plans, and more.
On Sunday, September 13, Democrat Senator Ruben Gallego was asked if he would tear down the new White House Ballroom, currently under construction, and new Triumphal Arch, still in the planning stages if he were elected President in 2028. “I think I’d be advocating for almost all of that,” he said in response. “The fact that he has destroyed the institutions that have kept this government together through some of the hardest times and eroded, for example, our Department of Justice is another reason why we need to be taking down all these, you know, honorific situations or emblems of him,” he added. After calling the proposed arch an “ugly monstrosity,” he continued “That arch is another reason why that needs to be taken care of. Because this man has done nothing but actually destroying the very fundamental things that these men and women have fought for, which is to save this country and continue this democracy.” He is not alone. Senator Chris Murphy, Representatives Steve Cohen, and Ted Lieu have all said something similar. In fact, Representative Lieu went one step further and claimed tearing down the ballroom, the arch, and everything else will be a key part of the Democrat’s 2028 agenda, posting on X, “Here is my prediction: the Democratic presidential candidate who promises to restore the White House to what it looked like pre Trump will win the primary and the Presidency.”
More figuratively speaking, Democrats and their progressive allies have been proposing a wide variety of initiatives that would tear down key aspects of our economy and our democracy, though they do not phrase it this way for obvious reasons. In this regard, the Democratic Socialists of America might be the most extreme with their desire to eliminate the Senate, the Supreme Court, and the Presidency, but they are not the only left-leaning grouping call for major structural changes to American life, essentially tearing things down and claiming they will build them back better to use President Joe Biden’s old slogan. Senator Bernie Sanders and others, for example, have recently called for the newly minted Democrat Congress to abolish the current private insurance market and replace it with Medicare-for-all. While they promise huge savings, improved coverage, and easier access to care, the reality is that our current plan would be torn away and replaced with the insurance they give you, whether you like it or not. They insist this will be better – more affordable, easier, whatever – but as the old saying goes, there’s no guarantee except their promises to that effect and if the past is prologue, to use another old line, there will at a minimum be massive disruption.
Barely 15 years ago, Democrats including President Barack Obama promised something similar in the most recent wholesale transformation of healthcare. As they sold it, the Affordable Care Act would reduce costs without interfering with your relationship with your doctor or requiring you to change insurance plans unless you wanted to for whatever reason, but that’s not what happened, far from it. Not only did costs skyrocket, rising much faster than inflation, the entire market was disrupted despite the promises, ultimately earning the infamous “Lie of the Year” award from Politifact of all places, not exactly a group unfriendly to Democrats. As they put it, the “promise was impossible to keep.” At the time, at least four million Americans lost their healthcare plans, causing Politifact to note the obvious, “Boiling down the complicated health care law to a soundbite proved treacherous, even for its promoter-in-chief. Obama and his team made matters worse, suggesting they had been misunderstood all along. The stunning political uproar led to this: a rare presidential apology.” They are referring to when the President himself appeared with NBC News’ Chuck Todd saying, “We weren’t as clear as we needed to be in terms of the changes that were taking place, and I want to do everything we can to make sure that people are finding themselves in a good position, a better position than they were before this law happened. And I am sorry that they are finding themselves in this situation based on assurances they got from me.”
The reason people ended up losing their plans is instructive as well. To quote Politifact again, “The Affordable Care Act tried to allow existing health plans to continue under a complicated process called ‘grandfathering,’ which basically said insurance companies could keep selling plans if they followed certain rules. The problem for insurers was that the Obamacare rules were strict. If the plans deviated even a little, they would lose their grandfathered status. In practice, that meant insurers canceled plans that didn’t meet new standards.” Incredibly, they failed to mention that losing your plan frequently means losing your doctor, even if you had a relationship with a preferred provider for years, but regardless, the root cause is the same: Obamacare tore down the existing plans and replaced them, leaving millions in a lurch. Considering that a federal takeover of healthcare is an even more complicated endeavor, where everyone will effectively be on the same plan, the risks of an even more major disruption and even larger broken promises are much, much higher. While I can understand the frustration with our healthcare system and have written on it myself, tearing it down and starting over, hoping for the best, isn’t the right solution, not when other options are available for reform. Indeed, such an approach is only likely to make things worse before – if – it ever makes them better.
Nor is that the only thing Democrats wish to tear down and theoretically rebuild. Immigration and Customs Enforcement is also a target. Senator Sanders himself called for the department to be disbanded as part of his plan for the Democrats to deliver for the working class along with the entire Congressional Progressive Caucus, the Justice Democrats, progressive firebrand Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, potential Presidential candidate Representative Ro Khanna and others. To them, the agency is beyond reform if not redemption, but perhaps needless to say, they never stop to consider the results and whether or not border security would be jeopardized if those in charge and the entire structure were suddenly replaced. Before President Trump retook office in 2025, border encounters never dropped below 144,000 per month throughout the entirety of fiscal 2024 (October to September), ranging from a peak of a truly astounding 370,883 in December 2023 and a low of 144,666 in September 2024 with an average of almost 8,000 encounters per day. These numbers however, have completely turned around since. Beginning in February 2025, the first full month in President Trump’s second term, encounters have barely exceeded 30,000 and have been as low as 24,589, averaging barely 1,000 per day, a dramatic drop. By any measure, this should be considered a success story, but Democrats still want to tear it down and start over with some unspecified new agency and approach.
To some extent, even their tax plan and plans for your retirement are the same. Senator Sanders and most recently, former Mayor and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg have called for a 5% wealth tax on billionaires, but what does that really mean? Even if we set aside that direct taxes are unconstitutional and in that sense, they would be tearing down one of the underpinnings of our very Republic, confiscating 5% of a person’s wealth every year, whether or not they spend or access the money, can also be considered tearing it down, but in this case the plan is to give it to the government, who they claim will give it to someone else. Once again, they promise there will be no unintended consequences, but never bother to explain how they can be sure what might happen if Elon Musk for example, was forced to sell 5% of his shares of Tesla every year, glutting the market. What do you think that will do to the value of the shares in your 401K or pension plan? Will it tear down your wealth as well? Considering the options the super wealthy have to relocate, shelter their assets, and otherwise avoid the tax rather than simply sell their shares at the government’s annual decree, these unintentional consequences are likely to be more severe than the estimated $43 billion the tax would raise per year, and yet they persist. On the retirement front, Senator Sanders also believes that some companies should be forced to return to old-school pension plans rather than the current 401k’s partially funded by employers and other investment tools, but there are problems with tearing down this private system as well. First, pension plans don’t always include spouses. Most companies ask you to pay more into them to cover a spouse after the employee dies, which could leave many without income. Second, pensions do not belong to you. The money dies when you die, and nothing is passed onto your loved ones, further tearing down your and their ability to earn wealth.
However you might personally feel about any of these issues, for a party that claims to be focused on affordability, they certainly seem to have other things on their mind.