Two speakers debate before a packed legislative chamber

No, you can’t govern from Congress even without the filibuster

As the battle over leadership in the Senate begins with whether or not to nuke the filibuster and Senator Bernie Sanders claims Democrats need to deliver for the working class, the risk of overpromising remains practically off the charts.

Democrats are necessarily elated by their huge win in the midterm elections earlier this month, but there appears to be some growing in the ranks confusion concerning their leadership and their ability as a party to get anything done from Congress alone.  While Representative Hakeem Jeffries is expected to have a reasonably smooth path to Speaker of the House next year, Senator Chuck Schumer is facing a challenge in his bid for Majority Leader from fellow Senator Chris Van Hollen despite flipping eight, likely nine seats in a single cycle, no mean achievement by historical standards.  Setting aside the irony that the Democrat’s fresh new leadership face might be a 67 year old white man as opposed to a 75 year old one, a key Van Hollen selling point is his desire to eliminate the filibuster and transform the Senate into an institution ruled by the majority, much more like the House of Representatives.  As he described it using the word personal at least a couple of times to perhaps blunt the edge of the proposal, “My personal opinion is that we need democracy in the United States Senate and that means allowing ultimately a majority of senators to answer the call of the American people, so that means 51 votes.”  “My personal view has been all along that the filibuster is an antidemocratic — small ‘d’ — provision. It’s not in our Constitution. It was put in there by senators to enhance their power over the power of the people,” he added.  “My view is we need to have a system where you have lots of debate, lots of debate, but at the end of the day, a majority reflecting the will of the people should be able to hold a view on an important measure.  This is an issue that I think we need to talk to the caucus about.”  As an example of what the Democrats might do without the filibuster, Senator Van Hollen went on to cite passing “democracy protection measures” on voting rights.

For his part, Senator Bernie Sanders, who has already said he will not support Senator Schumer for Majority Leader, is also interested in accomplishments.  In a recent opinion piece for Fox News of all places, the progressive firebrand declared, “There can be no more excuses. The new Democratic majority must now deliver for a long-neglected working class.”  In his view, voters said “No to Trump’s pathological lying, his contempt for the Constitution and the rule of law, his narcissism, his corruption and his disastrous policies. But they also said something more…They want an end to status quo politics and status quo policies that prop up a rigged economy and a corrupt campaign finance system.”  As a result of the Democrats “massive victory,” they “now have the votes to pass legislation that will greatly improve the lives of millions of working families. And that’s exactly what they must do. No more empty rhetoric and poll-driven messaging. No more telling people, over and over again, how terrible Donald Trump and the Republicans are. No more excuses. The new Democratic majority must deliver for a long-neglected working class.”  To do so, he proposed that Democrats nationalize healthcare by passing Medicare-for-all, beginning by lowering the “eligibility to 55, expand coverage to include dental, vision and hearing and guarantee health care for every child from birth through age 19” as part of a four year transition a fully government run system, pass a 5% wealth tax on billionaires that might or might not be Constitutional to “provide working-class families of four with a $12,000 direct payment, build 7 million affordable housing units, make public colleges and universities tuition-free, establish free child care for 13 million children and improve public education,” raise the minimum wage to at least $20 per hour, raise the payroll tax limit so that all income including dividends and capital gains is taxed to increase Social Security benefits by $2,400, somehow “restore guaranteed pensions so workers can retire with dignity,” pause advanced AI development, fight climate change by creating “millions of good-paying jobs by moving our energy systems away from fossil fuels and toward energy efficiency and sustainable energy, “end this disastrous war [in Iran], cut off funding for the genocidal government in Israel and substantially reduce military spending,” abolish ICE, pass comprehensive immigration reform, and “overturn Citizens United and abolish super PACs.”

Needless to say, this is quite a list in a world where passing a single one of these initiatives in any given year or term would be considered a huge achievement by any standard.  While Senator Sanders insists these policies aren’t “radical,” instead they are “mainstream ideas supported by strong majorities of the American people,” clearly passing a tax which might require a Constitutional amendment to implement and nationalizing about a fifth of the entire US economy is not going to be without unintended consequences whatever he may claim.  There are, of course, also questions about the cost.  Senator Sanders insisted the billionaire tax can pay for direct payments to families, new housing units, tuition free college, paid child care, and other unspecified educational programs, but the numbers do not appear close to adding up by any mathematics in the known universe.  Five percent of the wealth held by billionaires might sound like a lot in isolation, but there simply aren’t many of them to begin with, less than a thousand in the entire United States, however high you think they should be taxed.  Assuming these billionaires do not find a means to hide their money or shield it from the proposed tax, the measure is likely to raise around $4.4 trillion over ten years against an estimated cost of $2 trillion to $4 trillion for the new housing units alone, forget everything else.  Considering we are $40 trillion in debt already, have been facing deficits of more than a trillion per year since the pandemic and do not expect the gap to close much in the immediate future, it’s a pretty bizarre position, in my opinion at least, to believe trillions in additional spending will somehow deliver for the working class rather than wreck the economy for everyone.

Whatever the case, there’s also the risk that Senator Sanders might well be over promising and underdelivering.  The average person probably thinks delivering for the working class means the actual implementation of programs that will make their lives better in a measurable way, not merely passing bills that will ultimately be vetoed by President Donald Trump.  Indeed, the Senator himself noted this earlier in the same article, but then rather blithely dismissed it, “Will Trump veto that legislation? Maybe, maybe not. If he signs the bills, the American people will benefit and be grateful. If he doesn’t, Republicans will pay a terrible political price,” and yet it’s not remotely clear that’s the case.  Whether you support Senator Sander’s progressive goals or otherwise, there’s a reason why former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi famously or infamously quipped that Democrats needed to pass the Affordable Care Act to find out what’s in it.  Despite the short summaries Senator Sanders provided in his article – much of which is quoted above – these proposals are complex pieces of legislation with variously competing demands.  Senators will not simply vote yes on whatever happens to cross their desks because it has the right name on it, nor is the healthcare industry going to be nationalized by a 1-2 page bill that everyone can easily understand.  If Obamacare was any indication, the final bill will number in the thousands of pages and will necessarily contain dozens if not hundreds of trade offs if not outright onerous decisions beginning with how to fund it.

Contrary to the way it’s positioned in the media, Medicare-for-all isn’t free.  It’s funded by a massive tax increase that proponents claim will be offset by the costs for private plans, meaning your taxes might well go up by thousands of dollars a year or more, but your income will remain the same or potentially be even higher because you’re no longer paying for private coverage.  Even if we assume that’s true, how we get from one system to the other without paying more remains unknown because the system is extremely complicated.  Somewhere slightly under 160 million people, more than half of the population that isn’t already on Medicare, receive at least partially subsidized insurance through their employer.  While this money never lands in our bank account, it’s part of our salary structure and presumably, would need to be transitioned into a tax to fund Medicare-for-all, but what that actually looks like in practice when employers fund a different percentage by company not to mention offering a wide variety of different plans is entirely unclear.  Similarly, how to structure an increased payroll tax to fund a program where people currently pay an equal amount regardless of income is equally mysterious.  As of right now, whether you make $50,000 or $500,000, your healthcare costs are the same if you have the same plan and same number of dependents, but taxes don’t work that way.  Increasing the payroll tax on someone on the lower end of the income spectrum who has a family plan will not result in enough money to pay for their share of the new system.  There’s also the reality that most people on Medicare also have some kind of private plan, meaning any costs included in the bill are not likely to be complete, and of course, all of this doesn’t account for the uncomfortable truth that Medicare reimbursement rates are low, meaning it’s far from clear that coverage will equate to access to care, much less actual care.

Even if we’re extraordinarily generous and assume all of these problems can be solved, the political problem of having a massive bill that is not signed into law circulating in the public for months or potentially years is not exactly small.  Whatever Senator Sanders may insist, the likelihood of the bill becoming a target with Republicans admittedly cherry picking certain provisions, and forcing Democrats to defend them for an ongoing period, not to mention the possibility that healthcare providers will be forced to weigh in on whether they will even accept Medicare-for-all in the first place, is high.  Does Senator Sanders seriously believe Democrats are going to take months writing a bill, days if not weeks debating and passing it, fully knowing that it has no chance of becoming law anytime soon and Republicans will be happy to savage it in the meantime?  Anything’s possible, but that seems incredibly unlikely, if not actual political suicide.  It’s rare enough that a politician will support a controversial bill.  It’s practically unheard for them to do so knowing it’s not going to become law and the controversy might well be for nothing.

While I have focused on Medicaid-for-all here, the same is true of several of Senator Sander’s recommendations.  Do Democrats really want to spend months or years defending a bill that effectively opens up the border or at least will be characterized that way, or spends trillions on climate change at least partially by increasing gas prices people already think are too high? Ultimately, this is why it seems to me that abolishing the filibuster to pass bills the opposition President will undoubtedly veto is a complete folly.  Even if I disagree on the importance of the filibuster in general, I understand the appeal of making it easier to get things done when you are the party in power, but this wouldn’t do that.  Getting a bill passed still wouldn’t be easy and even if you succeeded, it would not be signed into law until and if a Democrat wins in 2028.  In other words, you simply can’t govern from Congress.  Republicans learned that lesson after putting up similar numbers against President Obama in 2010 and it seems Democrats are about to learn it anew.

Leave a Reply