Cloaked figure viewing a cemetery and castle through medieval windows

Does Hamlet fear life rather than death as he claims?

Over the course of the play, Hamlet asserts that life is both worth living and impossible to endure, only to reach the conclusion that it doesn’t matter anyway, but that doesn’t change the fact that it does.

When Hamlet contemplates suicide in the infamous “To be or not to be speech,” he does not give a rousing defense of life itself.  Rather than concluding people choose to stay in this world for the many pleasures it contains, those of flesh, family, faith, and more, he provides a detailed litany of the horrors, both big and small, that we might wish to escape, and interestingly, he spends a lot more time what we might call sweating the small stuff.  While Hamlet mentions “heart-ache” and “dispriz’d love,” most of what he refers to as “the thousand natural shocks that flesh is heir to” are what many would consider the minor indignities all of us endure, sometimes on a daily basis.  There is the normal aging process, which he characterizes as the “whips and scorns of time,” the “oppressor’s wrong,” which in this case we can take to mean an overbearing boss or superior, the “proud man’s contumely,” literally having to deal with an arrogant prick, the “law’s delay,” same as it in our time when the legal process is slow and justice can be long in coming, the “insolence of office,” essentially dealing with the equivalent of the Department of Motor Vehicles in Denmark long ago, and the “spurns That patient merit of the unworthy takes,” once again how hard it is to deal with people we might impolitely call complete assholes.  After asking who would endure this when they can so easily kill themselves, he adds a couple of more to the list, bearing burdens, and grunting and sweating under a life that’s “weary” – not dreadful, not horrific, not tragic, not excruciatingly painful, merely dull, boring, and tedious.

When you consider that Hamlet has just lost his father, his mother is sleeping with his uncle who killed that father, and he’s about to break it off with his lover Ophelia, the focus on the mundane is even stranger.  Here’s a man who has suffered some true hardships, who we can reasonably forgive being lost in grief to the point of possibly ending it all, and yet among the chief reasons he wishes to escape this world is dealing with difficult people, mentioning it five times as some sort of horror he cannot handle.  While I think most would agree in principle that fear of death and what comes after is at least one of the motivations that keeps us in this world and prevents us from doing the unthinkable, I doubt many would list the same minor indignities as their primary reasons to seek any escape. If they were Hamlet himself, thrust into the role, they likely would’ve listed the real hardships that had befallen him, and yet he doesn’t even allude to them, not once.  Conversely, this is also a man who has real reasons to live.  His dead father has charged him with avenging his death, if he does so he will become king, he will have freed his mother from the clutches of a man he considers evil and unworthy, and he will likely be able to consummate his relationship with Ophelia herself.  These are big things, the sort of potential life that most of us would never dream of even if the obstacle to get there is administering justice for the death of our father, but Hamlet doesn’t seem to care about that either.  To him, life is bad primarily because of the little things and his chief fear is that life after death will be worse somehow, that the dreams which will come will be too much to bear.  This “puzzles the will, And makes us rather bear those ills we have Than fly to others that we know not of.”

Ironically, he says this though he admitted to having bad dreams in the present earlier in the play and that he finds no enjoyment in life in general, upending the meaning of the soliloquy.  “O God, I could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself a king of infinite space–were it not that I have bad dreams,” a statement that occurs in the preceding act and frames the entire subject differently.  In this telling, Hamlet is content in and of himself right now – meaning he could bear all of the burdens he is about to describe – except that he’s plagued by dreams and an over active subconscious mind.  In the same scene, he reveals to Rosencrantz and Guildenstern that “I have of late, (but wherefore I know not) lost all my mirth, forgone all custom of exercises; and indeed, it goes so heavily with my disposition; that this goodly frame the earth, seems to me a sterile promontory; this most excellent canopy the air, look you, this brave o’er hanging firmament, this majestical roof, fretted with golden fire: why, it appeareth no other thing to me, than a foul and pestilent congregation of vapours. What a piece of work is a man, How noble in reason, how infinite in faculty, In form and moving how express and admirable, In action how like an Angel, In apprehension how like a god, The beauty of the world, The paragon of animals. And yet to me, what is this quintessence of dust? Man delights not me; no, nor Woman neither; though by your smiling you seem to say so.”

Two things jump out:  First, Hamlet insists he doesn’t know why he’s depressed, despite the fact that he just lost a father, a mother, and a kingdom, and is about to lose a lover.  Some critics might argue that he doesn’t want to reveal these facts to friends who have been co-opted by his uncle, but surely he would be aware they know Hamlet is in mourning and would readily attribute his mental state to the death of his father without leaping to the conclusion he was killed by his own brother.  Second, Hamlet completely subverts all of the reasons he’s about to claim are cause for suicide twice in the same scene, this time even more broadly and forcefully.  When he claimed to be “king of infinite space,” he was referring to himself, but now he extends that to the entire world and all of humanity.  Rather than spending our days suffering in some tedious hell, we inhabit a “goodly frame” of a world with an “excellent canopy,” a “brave” firmament, and a “majestical roof” over our heads.  Within this world, he likens us to gods, placing us above angels, animals, the beauty of the world, gifted with “noble” reason, “infinite” faculties,” and “admirable” motions.  Not long after all of this is gone, however, humans no longer bestride the earth like gods, and instead, our lives are miserable and brutish, all of our intellectual, physical, and environmental gifts replaced by simple weariness and minor sufferings we endure simply because of the potential for worse dreams to come.

On the surface, these statements seem completely incompatible.  We either live in this world because we have reason to – the world itself, our own abilities, and relationships – or because we’re too frightened of the afterlife, but Hamlet appears to ascribe to both views at the same time or at least in rapid succession.  He admits there are reasons to live, rejects them, and then focuses exclusively on reasons to die.  As if that wasn’t enough of a contradiction, later in the play he reframes the question that started the whole soliloquy in the first place.  When Hamlet said “To be or not to be,” he was referring to exist or not to exist, as in to be in the world or not be in it, but in the final act he tells Horatio that it’s not even a choice in the first place.  Rather that either being or not being, all things will both be and not be in their own course, “There’s special providence in the fall of a sparrow.  If it be now, ‘tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now; if it be not now, yet it will come—the readiness is all.”  Thus, the state of being itself is essentially a matter of timing.  The things that exist now, will cease to exist at some point, the things that existed at some point will not exist again, and the things that have not existed and do not currently exist, will exist at some point in their turn.  In this construction, choice is removed, only time and fortune matter, and the best we can do is be ready for anything.

While it has been remarked that Hamlet returns from his trip to England a changed man, it’s not clear that alone accounts for the contradictions.  Over the course of the play, he’s taken all sides of the issue to reach the conclusion that it doesn’t matter anyway, but that doesn’t change the fact that it does.  Everything Hamlet said earlier remains true.  The new framing doesn’t negate the reality that he still chooses to live for whatever reason; he can insist it’s left up to fate – the “special providence in the fall of a sparrow” – but he can just as easily pick up the dagger he mentioned earlier – technically, he referred to it as a “bare bodkin” – and kill himself.  Indeed, he’s about to make the fateful choice that leads to his death by agreeing to a duel with Laertes, Ophelia’s brother and Polonius’ son, to whose deaths Hamlet contributed to either directly or indirectly.  While Hamlet may think it’s fate that has led him to this choice, he still makes the actual choice.  Beyond killing himself, he could’ve simply chosen not to return to Denmark in the first place.  To me at least, Hamlet is far too intelligent and – at times – self aware not to realize this and to instead conclude that he’s nothing more than a leaf in the wind.

Ultimately, the only way any of this makes sense is a classic defense mechanism. Whatever situation Hamlet finds himself in, he rationalizes such that he can remain properly detached, setting himself apart by the means at his disposal and the thoughts that happen to be crossing through his mind.  The different concepts he reaches for in these moments aren’t relevant, only that he marshals them to his purposes.  Consciously, he understands that there is beauty and magic in the world – you don’t choose those words if you don’t see those things, and previously, before the play began he sent love letters to Ophelia, suggesting a purity of enjoyment in other people lacking afterwards – but something changed after his father died, even before he became aware that his uncle is a murderer.  While he claims to not know what that change is, the loss has clearly affected him deeply, causing him to withdraw from the world and do everything possible to remain apart.  In fact, this might be one of the key reasons he delays taking revenge on his uncle:  By doing so, he would become king and necessarily thrust in the center of the action.  From this perspective, it’s not Christian morality or something else that holds him back, it’s his own inability to cope with the loss of his father.  Otherwise, he makes these statements which seem contradictory on the surface as means to that end.  Even when he returns to Denmark and finally decides to take some action – at least to some extent, the duel is not his idea and is offered to him rather than making it happen – the defense mechanism persists, only this time he believes the future is best left up to fate rather than free will.  Regardless, it seems clear that Hamlet might fear life rather than death.

Leave a Reply